Difference between revisions of "Talk:Resource-Based Economic Model"
From The Crowdsourced Resource-Based Economy Knowledgebase
(Created page with "I will read this more carefully at some point and find a place to insert a section for core fundamentals of an RBE. The first one that springs to mind is the respect and valu...") |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | Please observe the following wiki etiquette (by [[User:Ziggy|veganforvenus]] ([[User talk:Ziggy|talk]]) 10:29, 14 November 2012 (EST)): | ||
| + | # Leave comments logged on as a user. Creating a user is very easy, and you can even login with your facebook user to make it even easier. Alternatively, if you must, please let us know who you are. | ||
| + | # Don't make personal remarks, opinions, or leave personal messages that do not add to the conversation, like "I'll read this more carefully later" | ||
| + | # When starting a new topic, name the topic enclosed within double equal signs at both sides (== example ==); if it is a subtopic, ensure it has one extra equal sign than the topic at both sides (=== sub-example===) | ||
| + | # When commenting on someone else's topic, begin the comment with a colon (: my comment); when commenting on a comment that has colons already, ensure the new comment has one extra colon (:: my reply to your comment) | ||
| + | # Leave a signature and a timestamp on comments added; this can easily be done by adding three (just the signature) or four (includes a timestamp) ~ signs together (e.g. <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>: the wiki engine will convert that before saving | ||
| + | # When adding a list of external links (e.g. videos), it is highly desirable to have next to each link a short description of them | ||
| + | |||
| + | == General notes == | ||
I will read this more carefully at some point and find a place to insert a section for core fundamentals of an RBE. | I will read this more carefully at some point and find a place to insert a section for core fundamentals of an RBE. | ||
| + | : Please state who you are, and if possible introduce yourself in your personal page. Also, ensure all comments are relevant and add to the conversation. | ||
| + | : When adding a new section, please ensure it is not redundant, and that it is properly documented. Alternatively, as it will be standard in this wiki, add your personal interpretation of an RBE (or disagreement with that stated in the RBE page) in your own personal page. This will enable, when there are enough of such pages, to make an analysis of where people generally coincide, and where there are varying opinions. [[User:Ziggy|veganforvenus]] ([[User talk:Ziggy|talk]]) 10:29, 14 November 2012 (EST) | ||
| + | == RBE Social values == | ||
| + | === Autonomy: Individualism vs Collectivism === | ||
The first one that springs to mind is the respect and valuing of individual autonomy, which differentiates an RBE from socialism which is collectivist. | The first one that springs to mind is the respect and valuing of individual autonomy, which differentiates an RBE from socialism which is collectivist. | ||
An RBE isn't really an RBE if it doesn't respect the freedom of the individual. This is very important, as any system, however well planned and intentioned, always turns fascist when it doesn't value the autonomy and sovereignty of individual human beings. | An RBE isn't really an RBE if it doesn't respect the freedom of the individual. This is very important, as any system, however well planned and intentioned, always turns fascist when it doesn't value the autonomy and sovereignty of individual human beings. | ||
| + | : Is this your interpretation? Can you back this information with relevant sources? Relevant sources are very important in this wiki; RBE is prone to interpretation and it must be very clear when definitions come from personal interpretation or from documented sources (ideally surveys!). [[User:Ziggy|veganforvenus]] ([[User talk:Ziggy|talk]]) | ||
| + | == RBE core elements == | ||
| + | === Abundance === | ||
The second is that an RBE isn't an RBE without economics predominantly based on '''abundance'''. As an RBE is about catering to the interests of the whole of humanity, rather than the interests of a select few. This is an element an RBE shares with socialism. But it's a case of collective good by way of individual freedom, rather than trying to reach an ideal of collective good and forcing it on the collective, which is ultimately therefore not in the interest of the collective anyway, because the collective is made up of individuals. | The second is that an RBE isn't an RBE without economics predominantly based on '''abundance'''. As an RBE is about catering to the interests of the whole of humanity, rather than the interests of a select few. This is an element an RBE shares with socialism. But it's a case of collective good by way of individual freedom, rather than trying to reach an ideal of collective good and forcing it on the collective, which is ultimately therefore not in the interest of the collective anyway, because the collective is made up of individuals. | ||
| + | : Abundance is a very important topic, but also one that involves many factors and is prone to interpretation. It is good material for its own page. [[User:Ziggy|veganforvenus]] ([[User talk:Ziggy|talk]]) | ||
| − | + | The term "Resource Based Economy" is based on the assumption that resources are for the most part abundant. So in order to be more clear, one could use the term "Abundant Resources Based Economy", or "Abundant Resources Based Economics". | |
| + | : This is an excellent comment and shall be present in the list of alternative names for RBE (as there have been many complaints that RBE is too vague a name, and often prone to misinterpretation). [[User:Ziggy|veganforvenus]] ([[User talk:Ziggy|talk]]) | ||
Some good videos on the topic of abundance in economics, explaining what it is, and why it's important: | Some good videos on the topic of abundance in economics, explaining what it is, and why it's important: | ||
| − | + | * http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6XAPnuFjJc&noredirect=1 | |
| − | http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6XAPnuFjJc&noredirect=1 | + | * http://www.ted.com/talks/peter_diamandis_abundance_is_our_future.html |
| − | + | * http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmSzqMLA670 | |
| − | http://www.ted.com/talks/peter_diamandis_abundance_is_our_future.html | + | * http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2xJ1CnVfsk&NR=1&feature=endscreen |
| − | + | * And here's David Suzuki describing how conventional economics is divorced from the wholistic interests of the worlds people: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Se55CCdfaOA | |
| − | http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmSzqMLA670 | + | |
| − | + | ||
| − | http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2xJ1CnVfsk&NR=1&feature=endscreen | + | |
| − | + | ||
| − | And here's David Suzuki describing how conventional economics is divorced from the wholistic interests of the worlds people: | + | |
| − | http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Se55CCdfaOA | + | |
Revision as of 09:29, 14 November 2012
Please observe the following wiki etiquette (by veganforvenus (talk) 10:29, 14 November 2012 (EST)):
- Leave comments logged on as a user. Creating a user is very easy, and you can even login with your facebook user to make it even easier. Alternatively, if you must, please let us know who you are.
- Don't make personal remarks, opinions, or leave personal messages that do not add to the conversation, like "I'll read this more carefully later"
- When starting a new topic, name the topic enclosed within double equal signs at both sides (== example ==); if it is a subtopic, ensure it has one extra equal sign than the topic at both sides (=== sub-example===)
- When commenting on someone else's topic, begin the comment with a colon (: my comment); when commenting on a comment that has colons already, ensure the new comment has one extra colon (:: my reply to your comment)
- Leave a signature and a timestamp on comments added; this can easily be done by adding three (just the signature) or four (includes a timestamp) ~ signs together (e.g. ~~~~: the wiki engine will convert that before saving
- When adding a list of external links (e.g. videos), it is highly desirable to have next to each link a short description of them
Contents |
General notes
I will read this more carefully at some point and find a place to insert a section for core fundamentals of an RBE.
- Please state who you are, and if possible introduce yourself in your personal page. Also, ensure all comments are relevant and add to the conversation.
- When adding a new section, please ensure it is not redundant, and that it is properly documented. Alternatively, as it will be standard in this wiki, add your personal interpretation of an RBE (or disagreement with that stated in the RBE page) in your own personal page. This will enable, when there are enough of such pages, to make an analysis of where people generally coincide, and where there are varying opinions. veganforvenus (talk) 10:29, 14 November 2012 (EST)
RBE Social values
Autonomy: Individualism vs Collectivism
The first one that springs to mind is the respect and valuing of individual autonomy, which differentiates an RBE from socialism which is collectivist. An RBE isn't really an RBE if it doesn't respect the freedom of the individual. This is very important, as any system, however well planned and intentioned, always turns fascist when it doesn't value the autonomy and sovereignty of individual human beings.
- Is this your interpretation? Can you back this information with relevant sources? Relevant sources are very important in this wiki; RBE is prone to interpretation and it must be very clear when definitions come from personal interpretation or from documented sources (ideally surveys!). veganforvenus (talk)
RBE core elements
Abundance
The second is that an RBE isn't an RBE without economics predominantly based on abundance. As an RBE is about catering to the interests of the whole of humanity, rather than the interests of a select few. This is an element an RBE shares with socialism. But it's a case of collective good by way of individual freedom, rather than trying to reach an ideal of collective good and forcing it on the collective, which is ultimately therefore not in the interest of the collective anyway, because the collective is made up of individuals.
- Abundance is a very important topic, but also one that involves many factors and is prone to interpretation. It is good material for its own page. veganforvenus (talk)
The term "Resource Based Economy" is based on the assumption that resources are for the most part abundant. So in order to be more clear, one could use the term "Abundant Resources Based Economy", or "Abundant Resources Based Economics".
- This is an excellent comment and shall be present in the list of alternative names for RBE (as there have been many complaints that RBE is too vague a name, and often prone to misinterpretation). veganforvenus (talk)
Some good videos on the topic of abundance in economics, explaining what it is, and why it's important:
- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6XAPnuFjJc&noredirect=1
- http://www.ted.com/talks/peter_diamandis_abundance_is_our_future.html
- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmSzqMLA670
- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i2xJ1CnVfsk&NR=1&feature=endscreen
- And here's David Suzuki describing how conventional economics is divorced from the wholistic interests of the worlds people: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Se55CCdfaOA
